ISSN 0130-0083
En Ru
ISSN 0130-0083
Two leaves with the old testament scenes in the context of current studies of models and copying processes in Rheno-Mosan art of the 12th century

Abstract

The Library of the University of Liege (Université de Liège. Bibliothèque, Ms. 2613) and the Victoria and Albert Museum in London (Victoria and Albert Museum, Ms. 413) have two leaves created c. 1150–1170 and produced in the Meuse region. Although the question of the purpose of the leaves is under discussion, these two oeuvres of Romanesque book illumination have not yet received special scholarly attention. The leaves have a similar layout: each side contains two compositions based on stories from the Book of Genesis, and there are no inscriptions or biblical quotations. The Old Testament episodes included in the pictorial program of the leaves do not form a consistent narrative cycle. Thus, the scenes of the sacrifice by Cain and Abel and the murder of Abel by Cain in the leaf from the Victoria and Albert Museum are followed by an episode of the meeting of Abraham and Melchizedek. The leaf from Liège begins with the scene of the sacrifice of Isaac. The cycle does not contain a number of scenes with a fairly consistent iconographic tradition (for example, the story of Noah). Such narrative heterogeneity can be interpreted through the prism of the purpose of the pictorial series. The Sacrifice of Abel, the Gifts of Melchizedek and the Sacrifice of Isaac by Abraham are mentioned in the Eucharistic Canon of the Sacramentary of Pope Gelasius I and have been used in iconographic programs since the era of early Christianity as the main liturgical prototypes. The back of the leaf from the Library of the University of Liege contains another subject which alludes to the typological parallelism of the Testaments – the Blessing of Ephraim and Manasseh by Jacob. The designated subjects can be found in a number of contemporaneous works of decorative and applied arts and book miniatures of the Rhine-Meuse region, which are compiled on the basis of typological logic in the arrangement of stories. The selection of stories, as well as the stylistic and iconographic analysis of the range of oeuvres with typological iconography, suggests that the leaves could have been fragments of a model book and probably served as models in the process of the spreading of the compositional and iconographic techniques which were characteristic of the Rhine-Meuse region

References

Balace S. Historiographie de l’art mosan. Th èse soutenue à l’université de Liège. Liège: L’université de Liège, 2009. 937 p.

Chapman G. Jacob Blessing the Sons of Joseph: A Mosan Enamel in the Walters Art Gallery // Th e Journal of the Walters Art Gallery. 1980. Vol. 38. P. 34–59.

Collon-Gevaert S. Quelques miniatures mosanes du XIIe siècle // Revue belge d’archéologie et d’histoire de l’art. Bruxelles: l’Académie royale d’archéologie de Belgique, 1935. T. 5. P. 17–25.

Descatoire Ch. Un ensemble d’émaux de la seconde moitié du XIIe siècle: les plaques de la cathédrale de Troyes, infl uences et spécifi cités // L’oeuvre de Meuse II: Orfèvrerie septentrionale XIIe et XIIIe siècles / Ed. par Ph. George. Liège: Institut du Patrimoine Wallon, 2018. Р. 49–65.

Grabar A., Nordenfalk C. Romanesque Painting from the Eleventh to the Thirteenth Century. Geneva: Skira, 1958. 230 p.

Klemm E. Ein romanischer Miniaturenzyklus aus dem Maasgebiet. Vienna: Adolf Holzhausens, 1973. 104 S.

Leclerq-Marx J. Autour de la Bible de Floreff e (région mosane, c. 1160): questions d’iconographie // Bulletin des Musées Royaux d’Art et d’Histoire. Bruxelles. Vol. 85/86. 2019. P. 71–84.

Macarenko A. L’Évangéliaire d’Averbode. Herent: Peeters, 2020. 60 p.

Mosaner Psalter-Fragment / Komm. H. Swarzenski. Graz: Akademische Druckund Verlagsanstalt, 1974. 20 S. Pächt O. Book Illumination in the Middle Ages. London: H. Miller Publishers; New York: Oxford University Press, 1986. 221 p.

Pozhidayeva A.V. Tsikl Tvoreniya v zapadnoyevropeyskom iskusstve XI — nachala XIII vv.: opyt ikonografi cheskoy genealogii: avtoreferat diss. … kandidata iskusstvovedeniya [The Cycle of Creation in Western European Art from the 11th through Early 13th Century: A Case of Iconographic Genealogy: Abstract of the Diss. for the Degree of Candidate of Art History and Criticism]. Moscow: MGU, 2008. 35 p.

Rhein und Maas. Kunst und Kultur 800–1400. Eine Ausstellung des Schnütgen- Museums der Stadt Köln und der belgischen Ministerien für französische und niederländische Kultur. Band 1. Köln: Schnütgen-Museum, 1972. 425 S. Band 2. Köln: Schnütgen-Museum, 1973. 510 S. Schapiro M. An Illuminated English Psalter of the Early Th irteenth Century // Journal of the Warburg and Courtauld Institutes. 1960. Vol. 23. P. 179–189.

Scheller R.W. Exemplum: Model-Book Drawings and the Practice of Artistic Transmission in the Middle Ages (Ca. 900 – Ca. 1470). Amsterdam: Amsterdam Univer sity Press, 2000. 434 p.

Stratford N. Three English Romanesque Enamelled Ciboria // The Burlington Magazine. 1984. Vol. 126. N 973. P. 204–217.

PDF, ru

Received: 11/15/2022

Accepted date: 02/28/2023

Keywords: medieval book illumination; Christian iconography; typology; Old Testament prefigurations; Harmony of the Testaments,; Rheno-Mosan art; medieval model books

Available in the on-line version with: 28.02.2023

To cite this article:
Issue 1, 2023